Category: ALP

The two envoys

The Prime Minister says he has appointed an antisemitic envoy and will soon appoint an islamophobia envoy, because the population does not understand the complexity and seriousness apparent in a perceived threat to Australia’s social cohesion. But the boot is on the other foot. He and his government have shown an abysmal lack of understanding or perhaps wilful blindness to the causes of misplaced anger with racist overtones. Defacing war memorials and attacking the offices of members of parliament, which I do not condone, are protests against our government for not sanctioning Israel for its gross violations of international law.

The two envoys

Anthony Albanese’s abuse of FOI laws and lack of transparency to be investigated by Senate InquiryKangaroo Court of Australia

Dowling seems to expect Albanese to walk on water, orat least turn it into wine, and do it NOW!! The ALP have hardly in power this century but Dowling raises the chant we so often hear. “When do we want it? We want it now”. There are many faults surfacing but they aren’t all Albanese’s Shane.

Anyway, Rex Patrick of Michael West Media is way ahead of Dowling on the problem of the FOI. He’s taking them to court to try to set a precedent. So much so the head of the FOI has resigned. Dowling is merely climbing on Patricks shoulders and shouting to stay relevant it seems.

Anthony Albanese’s handiwork in abusing FOI laws is about to come under close scrutiny after the Senate voted to hold an Inquiry. Governments are notorious for abusing Freedom of Information laws to hide government corruption from the media and public and the Albanese government has quickly shown they are no exception.

Source: Anthony Albanese’s abuse of FOI laws and lack of transparency to be investigated by Senate InquiryKangaroo Court of Australia

Filed under:

Climate Change Authority releases Review of International Offsets – » The Australian Independent Media Network

What this seems to indicate is back to the Rudd/Gillard future and that comprehensive Carbon Trading Scheme that Tony Abbott’s LNP set out to destroy by calling it a tax. The report echoes the fact that our Nation has lost 10 years of possible progress towards becoming a global leader rather than the number one laggard when tackling carbon emissions.

Climate Change Authority Media ReleaseReleased today, the Climate Change Authority’s Review of International Offsets finds the international carbon market is still evolving in response to the Paris Agreement and calls for publication of a National Carbon Market Strategy that makes the most of this opportunity for Australia to accelerate ambition on emissions reduction.The review finds that while carbon is priced and traded in Australia, the market is fragmented, inefficient and complicated.

Climate Change Authority releases Review of International Offsets – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Be progressive, Albo, don’t implement Stage 3 tax cuts

Labor is pushing ahead with Stage 3 tax cuts to benefit the wealthy, but with so many Australians struggling to make ends meet, IA founder and publisher Dave Donovan argues that the timing couldn’t be worse.

Be progressive, Albo, don’t implement Stage 3 tax cuts

Government stands by renewables goal as Dutton flags opposition

renewables-electricity-prices

The ALP government confirms their action to increase renewables in order to reduce energy costs and emissions. While Dutton confirms nothing but a promise of opposition to the government offering no alternatives.

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton signalled the Coalition would not support legislation for a more expensive, 43 per cent emissions reduction target by 2030 but declined to specify the size of its own, more modest target. “We will announce that before the next election,” Mr Dutton told the ABC.

Source: Government stands by renewables goal as Dutton flags opposition

Alan Kohler: In case of recession, Albanese must don a Teflon overcoat

recession kohler albanese

Governments usually change after a recession, not before one, so the job is a nice one – to manage the recovery. But this time is different.

So the number one political imperative in Anthony Albanese’s first term is fast becoming the need to make sure he is not blamed in three years’ time for the various crises he has been bequeathed.

He will especially need to find a Teflon recession coat. Tuesday’s minimum wage decision, in line with his own submission, won’t help.
Economic prospects are now changing rapidly as the Reserve Bank belatedly engineers a slowdown to deal with inflation. It will be touch and go whether there’s a recession.

Source: Alan Kohler: In case of recession, Albanese must don a Teflon overcoat

Labor tells a story without pictures: now that’s confidence – Michael West

Around this time in the 2019 campaign, the confidence that was bubbling throughout the Labor camp burst out into full hubristic glory.

One leading daily posed the ALP team in chiaroscuro, looking one part Sopranos cast, one part corporate raiders. Bristling with purpose, they looked. The new crew. The mean machine. The none-too subtle message: Bill Shorten’s team is ready, ready to rule.

Meanwhile Chris Bowen’s Facebook page featured himself and four sober-suited colleagues in an impersonation of a high-end law firm: himself, deputy leader Tanya Plibersek, a chin-stroking Shorten, Jim Chalmers and Penny Wong.

When the serious quintet’s big play went unstuck, one user commented: ”All dressed up and nowhere to go.”

Contrast all that with Campaign ’22. Yes, Albo has modeled some groovy threads to go with his trimmer physique. But the group photoshoot has gone the way of Shorten’s jibes about the big end of town. No more moody magnificence.

Labor candidates emphasise how rare it is for their party to win from opposition. The years it has happened since the war are cited like bingo numbers: 72, 83, 07. It’s the talk of the poker player holding a straight flush.

Source: Labor tells a story without pictures: now that’s confidence – Michael West

Election 2022: Anthony Albanese holds out promise of economic reform to lift wages

Anthony Albanese named universal childcare as the legacy he would like to leave if he became prime minister.

Labor leader Anthony Albanese has vowed to revive a “spirit of consensus” between unions and employers to lift wages and profits in an economic pitch to industry leaders that emphasised his willingness to tackle major reform if he wins power at the election.

Source: Election 2022: Anthony Albanese holds out promise of economic reform to lift wages

Labor to unveil plan to tackle China expansionism in the Pacific

Restoring Radio Australia is just one of 6 changes planned. There is already a generation of islanders less attached to Australia because of the LNP

Broadcasting and publishing content into the region will promote “Australian identity, values, and interests”, while partnerships and training with Pacific journalists will be strengthened. Increased funding for the public broadcaster is one of seven key points in the party’s plan to step up in the Pacific.

Source: Labor to unveil plan to tackle China expansionism in the Pacific

Peter Malinauskas leads Labor revival in SA as Liberals wiped out

Labor has swept into power in South Australia after just one term in the political wilderness in an emphatic result that has seen the Marshall Government turfed from office – and the Premier coming close to losing his seat. Despite successive polls suggesting a statewide swing to Labor, many in the Liberal camp had been hopeful of sandbagging key marginal seats and hanging onto power – but a red wave instead swept those electorates and more besides.

Source: Peter Malinauskas leads Labor revival in SA as Liberals wiped out

Anthony Albanese: It’s time to seize a once-in-a-generation opportunity

anthony albanese a better future

While the Morrison-Joyce government has spent years ridiculing renewables and struggling to come up with a viable energy policy, Labor has a plan for Australia to seize the opportunities of the age of renewables. It is a plan to build new industrial capacity, back it in with skills training and work with industry to shape change to the national interest. If successful in the coming election we will establish a National Reconstruction Fund to help drive our post-pandemic rebuild.

Source: Anthony Albanese: It’s time to seize a once-in-a-generation opportunity

Anthony Albanese to embrace Labor luminary Bob Hawke’s consensus style if ALP wins election | Anthony Albanese | The Guardian

Labor leader Anthony Albanese

Here is what the L-NP haven’t been doing for over 9 years even among themselves. Theirs is CHAOS STYLE!!

Anthony Albanese will bemoan a lost decade of division and policy inertia under the Coalition, declaring he will take his lead from Bob Hawke, lifting productivity, boosting growth and using “cheap, renewable energy to transform our economy” if Labor wins the coming election.

Source: Anthony Albanese to embrace Labor luminary Bob Hawke’s consensus style if ALP wins election | Anthony Albanese | The Guardian

Anthony Albanese says Australia has slipped to 59th in the world for average broadband speeds since the Coalition took office. Is that correct? – ABC News

Anthony Albanese wearing glasses and speaking at a doorstop. Verdict: checks out with a green tick

WHO DO YOU TRUST?

Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese says Australia’s has slipped to 59th in the world in the average broadband speed rankings. Is he correct? RMIT ABC Fact Check investigates.

Source: Anthony Albanese says Australia has slipped to 59th in the world for average broadband speeds since the Coalition took office. Is that correct? – ABC News

‘No more caps, no more closures’: Vic dumps almost all virus rules

COVID-19

Why 60% Vic supports Dan.. He does what he says and it’s for the benefit of the “common good”

Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews has announced a widespread easing of virus rules from midnight Thursday, declaring “no more caps, no more closures” in the state. It came with Victoria poised to tick over 90 per cent of over-12s fully vaccinated on Saturday or Sunday.

Source: ‘No more caps, no more closures’: Vic dumps almost all virus rules

‘Not like Tony Abbott’: what kind of PM would Anthony Albanese be? | Anthony Albanese | The Guardian

With Covid dominating the political agenda, Anthony Albanese has sought to make Scott Morrison the story

Albanese’s problem isn’t disapproval, it’s voters continuing to sit on the fence when changing a government requires an active choice. Change requires engagement, and around a quarter of the Guardian Essential sample can’t say whether they approve or disapprove of Albanese. This is a high number, and it’s been that way for many months. This fortnight’s Guardian Essential data neatly lays out a story of two leaders: Morrison’s approval has slipped, and his negatives are on the rise. That’s what happens when you stay in politics for a long time. Voters learn to decode your habits, and mark you down when strategy too often substitutes for sincerity. But Albanese hasn’t yet cut through sufficiently to convince voters he’s the change the country needs.

Source: ‘Not like Tony Abbott’: what kind of PM would Anthony Albanese be? | Anthony Albanese | The Guardian

The secret life of Bob Hawke: U.S. informant

Hawke worked hard at protecting American interests in Australia. By the time he left office in 1991, says Coventry, scholars agreed that Hawke’s Government ‘had virtually outdone previous conservative governments in proclaiming its support for Washington’. What Hawke’s first Foreign Minister, Bill Hayden, saw as Hawke’s ‘uncritical support for the USA’, Hawke couched as his belief in America, ‘whatever its mistakes’.

Source: The secret life of Bob Hawke: U.S. informant

‘It’s time’ — for another Labor split

A split of the Labor Party would be for the benefit of workers and progressives.

Source: ‘It’s time’ — for another Labor split

An open letter to members of the Parliamentary Labor Party – » The Australian Independent Media Network

To all parliamentary members, As a member of the Labor party, I am pleading with you, the federal parliamentary members, to stop what you are doing for a moment and ask yourself the following questions: Do you want to be the next government? Do you want to win the next election? Two simple questions, both of which should evoke a resounding, YES response. If they don’t, you should not be there. One more question : Are you willing to do what is necessary to achieve an election victory? If the answer is NOT YES, then for Christ’s sake, get out of the way!

Source: An open letter to members of the Parliamentary Labor Party – » The Australian Independent Media Network

To Win Back Support From Coal Miners, Labor Must Back a Green New Deal

The Australian Labor Party’s fossil fuel faction claims that Labor lost the Upper Hunter by-election because it didn’t back coal enthusiastically enough. But this strategy is the road to nowhere for workers and the ALP alike. To win back its lost supporters, the ALP must back a Green New Deal.

Source: To Win Back Support From Coal Miners, Labor Must Back a Green New Deal

Labor to target jobs growth with clean energy, avoids gas fired recovery

Labor’s climate change and energy spokesman Chris Bowen says clean energy investment can grow regional industrial jobs.

Source: Labor to target jobs growth with clean energy, avoids gas fired recovery

Labor’s Penny Wong, Bill Shorten highlight Morrison government’s gender crisis

Penny Wong says an Albanese Labor government would build a fairer society, a stronger nation and a better world.

In an earlier interview on the Nine Network’s Today show, Mr Albanese said Mr Morrison “doesn’t quite get it yet”. “We need to address gender inequality in our society. That’s why we put our childcare policy at the centre of our budget reply last year. That’s why we need to address issues like domestic and family violence leave. That’s why we need to address the issue of women’s representation in our national Parliament,” he said.

Labor’s Penny Wong, Bill Shorten highlight Morrison government’s gender crisis

Joel Fitzgibbon Helps Albo Show Who’s In Charge! – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Still after Brexit, Donald Trump, Boris Johnson, Scott Morrison and everything else that’s happened, betting on the most unlikely result would have made some people rich!

Joel Fitzgibbon Helps Albo Show Who’s In Charge! – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Unflappable unions remain focused versus IR reform bills – » The Australian Independent Media Network

In fact, Sally McManus, the national secretary of the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU), has applied the blowtorch to the government – in the hottest of acetylene fashions, yet in her characteristic calm, measured delivery – in claiming that all of the hard work of the previous five months of industrial relations reform negotiations has been undone.

Unflappable unions remain focused versus IR reform bills – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Casuals due to get relief in Victoria, in lieu of national action – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Dan Andrews isn’t just a carping Michael O’Brien

“This isn’t going to solve the problem of insecure work overnight, but someone has to put their hand up and say we’re going to take this out of the ‘too hard’ basket and do something about it – and that’s exactly what we’re doing,” he said.

Casuals due to get relief in Victoria, in lieu of national action – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Labor claims victory to win third term in Queensland

Annastacia Palaszczuk shares a hug with her father, former Labor minister Henry Palaszczuk, after winning her third term as Queensland premier.

Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk has won her third state election for Labor in a stunning endorsement of her tough border policy after an election campaign dominated by the state’s response to the COVID crisis.

Labor claims victory to win third term in Queensland

The real Albo finally stood up

The people of Australia asked Anthony Albanese to stand up and in his Budget reply, he has done just that. But ultimately, we will have to wait and see if this return to the firebrand Albanese of old is permanent.

The real Albo finally stood up

Victory for Andrews Labor Government as anti-wage theft law is passed

Anyone feel there’s a concerted effort to “Get Andrews” maybe because he’s doing a real job. (ODT)

The Wage Theft Bill, was viewed as a cornerstone promise in Premier Daniel Andrews’s state re-election campaign in 2018. It now sees guilty parties – such as business owners, managers, shopkeepers and accountants, or anyone connected to a business enterprise – who deliberately withhold award wages and related entitlements established under the Fair Work Act (2009) from their workers risk prison sentences up to ten years and face fines upwards of $198,264 for individuals and $991,320 for companies.

via Victory for Andrews Labor Government as anti-wage theft law is passed

Adem Somyurek sacked as Victorian Labor minister after explosive allegations of branch stacking | Victorian politics | The Guardian

Adem Somyurek

via Adem Somyurek sacked as Victorian Labor minister after explosive allegations of branch stacking | Victorian politics | The Guardian

Society must not ‘snap back’ to insecure work and poverty after coronavirus crisis, Albanese says | Australia news | The Guardian

Anthony Albanese

What the LNP call “casual work” is actually “precarious”. With the destruction of unions a priority work became increasingly “precarious ” or “insecure”. How did it get this way when Royal Commissions found trade unions to be basically honest and Banks and Business callous and corrupt. Where was the ALP during all of this?(ODT)

Australians deserve better than a post-crisis “snapback” to an economy in which workers worry about job insecurity while jobseekers are relegated to poverty, Anthony Albanese will declare on Monday.

In his latest “headland” speech, the Labor leader will sharpen his message that the public is looking for a recovery “in which no one is left behind” and will not accept a return to “the law of the jungle and unfettered market forces”.

via Society must not ‘snap back’ to insecure work and poverty after coronavirus crisis, Albanese says | Australia news | The Guardian

Albo Enters the Lion’s Den: The Sky Interview, Part One – » The Australian Independent Media Network

 Albo Enters the Lion’s Den: The Sky Interview, Part One – » The Australian Independent Media Network

and

Albo in The Lion’s Den: The Sky Interview,…Part Two

We pick up with Mr. Albanese and the trained monkey already in…

Labor, Coal and Climate Action – » The Australian Independent Media Network

via Labor, Coal and Climate Action – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Andrews signs new belt-and-road deal with China: ‘the right thing to do’

Premier Daniel Andrews signed the agreement with China on Wednesday night.

Victoria has signed a fresh deal with the Chinese government and its global ‘Belt and Road’ infrastructure project with Premier Daniel Andrew urging other Australian governments to follow suit.

The agreement, signed in Beijing on Wednesday evening, will deepen cooperation between the state and the Communist-ruled country in the key areas of infrastructure, innovation, ageing and trade development.

Wednesday’s deal was signed only a few hours after federal Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton questioned whether the Premier’s trade efforts in China were in the “national interest”.

via Andrews signs new belt-and-road deal with China: ‘the right thing to do’

Bring Back The Labor Herald – » The Australian Independent Media Network

The Liberals will put the country in such a bad state by the end of this term. We should see people return to Labor in droves. However, that is not what I want to see.

I want people to return to Labor in droves because they fully support Labor. That is Labor, a positive, progressive party, who places the worker and disadvantaged at its core.

I want people to return to Labor in droves because negative messaging by the right-wing and Greens has not flourished. I want people constantly talking about the Labor agenda and why we need it.

We can do this! Let’s resurrect the Labor Herald.

via Bring Back The Labor Herald – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Federal election: First Asian-Australian foreign minister would send strong message, Penny Wong says – Australia Votes – Federal Election 2019 – Politics – ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)

Penny Wong smiles with her left fist in the air.

Penny Wong says Australia will send a powerful symbolic message to the region if she becomes the first Asian-Australian appointed foreign minister.

via Federal election: First Asian-Australian foreign minister would send strong message, Penny Wong says – Australia Votes – Federal Election 2019 – Politics – ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)

Federal Election 2019: Key economist Warwick McKibbin lends weight to Labor’s climate policy

Bill Shorten's use of international carbon permits has been backed.

Both major parties have cited a report by Professor McKibbin in 2015 to back their claims, but he said his latest work showed the economic impact would be smaller than thought four years ago because of advances in technology.

Sorry Morrison go back to the books (ODT)

Federal Election 2019: Key economist Warwick McKibbin lends weight to Labor’s climate policy

How Australia strayed from a fair go to record inequality

Business and Banking call for CALMNESS. Workers beg for FAIRNESS (ODT)

Union members will stand together, whether it’s against a bullying local manager, or an entire wages system that profits only the very few, but there’s one issue that always receives unanimous and overwhelming support from the people I meet – that everyone needs to pay their fair share of tax.

Australia’s unionists may not all know the complexities of how tax avoidance operates, and they may not be across the ins and outs of each tax-minimising loophole and rort, but the reluctance of Australia’s rich to make taxation contributions that are in any way proportional to their wealth is as well known as it is enraging. When I explain to meetings of our members that there are 62 Australians who each earned $1 million last year and paid not one cent in tax – not even the Medicare levy – it is pitchfork time.

How Australia strayed from a fair go to record inequality

‘It’s a thumping’: Labor wins Northern Territory election | Australia news | The Guardian

Outgoing chief minister Adam Giles delivers a succinct obituary for his one-term government, which had its 2012 16-seat win cut to two seats

Source: ‘It’s a thumping’: Labor wins Northern Territory election | Australia news | The Guardian

Everybody Lost Their Collective Shit For Labor’s Former Prime Ministers – BuzzFeed News

But there was one missing, of course.

Source: Everybody Lost Their Collective Shit For Labor’s Former Prime Ministers – BuzzFeed News

Labor’s Legacy Shines Through – » The Australian Independent Media Network

By Callen Sorensen-Karklis The 21st century Labor Party has a lot to offer Australians, despite being written off in recent times as a party of disunity during its 2007 – 2013 period of government. Labor still has a profound legacy that has helped positively steer Australia’s place in the world in the Asian century. Although…

Source: Labor’s Legacy Shines Through – » The Australian Independent Media Network

How Bill Shorten has the tactical edge on Malcolm Turnbull

Most of us have highly stereotypical, caricatured views of the parties’ respective strengths and weaknesses.

Source: How Bill Shorten has the tactical edge on Malcolm Turnbull

Labor Claims NBN Staffer Took Photos Of Unreleased NBN Policy – BuzzFeed News

ALP fear their National Broadband Network policy has been leaked to the Liberal Party.

Source: Labor Claims NBN Staffer Took Photos Of Unreleased NBN Policy – BuzzFeed News

Labor can win the next election on tax reform – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Before the last election Tony Abbott, like John Howard before him, promised there would be no change to the GST.  Joe Hockey and Andrew Robb reiterated that promise in their final update on election commitments published on September 5, 2013. It confirms once and for all that: There are no cuts to education, health, defence…

Source: Labor can win the next election on tax reform – » The Australian Independent Media Network

Anthony Albanese Is Not Too Left Wing To Win Government. Indeed, He’s About Right – New Matilda

The common media narrative on the ‘left’ of the Labor Party is that it’s leaders, like Anthony Albanese, are unelectable. John Passant disagrees.

Source: Anthony Albanese Is Not Too Left Wing To Win Government. Indeed, He’s About Right – New Matilda

The Colossus of Cabramatta – Part One

Image from 3aw.com.au

The ALP, the Liberals, and the Greens – all trying to rewrite history in their own ink, for their own gain. Nick’s three-part series will set the record straight.

Myth # 1 – “The Whitlam Government was a shining example of progressive politics. Just like The Greens”.

This is a disgusting cheap shot and the biggest insult of all. Gough Whitlam’s entire political life was dedicated to the ALP. Never once did the man work for another party, never once did he renounce his faith, and never once did he align himself with the ridiculous noise that passes for “policy” on the far-left.

Within days of Gough’s passing, The Greens had the shameless audacity to post an image of the man with the caption “Vale Gough Whitlam” adjacent to their logo. They have since justified this mockery by blurring the memory of Gough’s ideas, picking and choosing a handful of their own, then dressing up them both up to make them seem like two peas in a pod. Nothing could be further from the truth.

For a start, Gough had no time for the pitiful ordeal of “protest politics”. Yelling slogans on a sunny afternoon, throwing a spanner into the works of anything and everything for the sake of it, then patting yourself on the back was never his style. Gough understood power was only useful by those who held it – which is how and why brought Labor back into power. The Greens have always been no more than a noisy fringe group, and so shall they remain forevermore.

Secondly, the Whitlam government had detailed, costed policies. Some worked, some didn’t. Regardless, these policies were based on extensive, evidence-based research, consultation with business, unions, academics, policy experts, community leaders, and the heads of government departments. While you can’t please everyone, Gough wanted to involve as much of the country as possible. Labor and Liberal have both used this approach – so much of their success or failure hinges on how well they pull this off. The Greens have never done this, nor will they ever. While the country gathers inside the political tent to sort out its problems, they stand outside pissing in.

Greenies have since offered the timid excuse that “the modern ALP bears no resemblance to the ALP Gough ran”, as though this somehow makes Gough a Greenie by default. This is a desperate attempt to climb back out of the gutter. The entire nation bears little resemblance the Australia of the 1970s. The entire world, in fact. The political landscape has been completely transformed, as both major parties have lurched to the right and the old socialist-capitalist warfare has faded. A new era of free market economics reigns supreme.

To claim Whitlam as a Green simply because the times suit them would be as pathetic and low as the ALP claiming Menzies as one of their own. Our longest serving PM and a blue-blooded Liberal, he ran targeted deficits when needed, expanded access to tertiary education, boosted immigration, funded the Snowy Mountains Hydro Scheme to deliver clean energy to the country, launched ABC television, pushed for aboriginal voting rights, boosted foreign aid, and built close ties with Singapore and Malaysia. The ALP could argue that this makes the bloke Labor through and through.

But they’ve got their own heroes – Keating, Curtin, Chifley, Hawke, and of course, Whitlam. The Liberals have the likes of Menzies and Howard. Even the bogans in Queensland who vote One Nation or The Nationals had Pauline Hanson and Joh Bjelke-Petersen. The Greens? Not one noteworthy, charismatic, or influential character. The closest they’ve come is Bob Brown – who was accurately described by one of Keating’s speechwriters as a bloke who looks, acts, and preaches like a Mormon on a bicycle missing his other half. Neither he nor his party have ever come close to legend status.

The Greens are spineless and desperate – Gough lived and died as a man of the Australian Labor Party.

Gough Whitlam’s fiscal legacy using facts

 

Within hours of the news that Gough Whitlam had died, age 98, the mantra of ‘hopeless economic management’ started to flow.

According to those who clearly loathe Whitlam and anything vaguely socially progressive, Fairfax and The Australian had stories where the Tea Party faithful in Australia wrote or were quoted saying, Whitlam was the worst Prime Minister Australia had seen, he was economically damaging, that he set up the culture of entitlement especially for health and university education, that he created the mentality of the dole bludger and so on.

I am sure you get the drift.

The criticisms were, as far as I can tell, nothing to do with managing the macroeconomy or the budget. They were focussed on the perception that he allocated too much government money to healthcare, education and the aged. That may or may not be the case, but no one has said why it matters or indeed, by how much the spending was excessive and exactly why it remains a problem.

No one has articulated and demonstrated why the clear and dramatic lift in government spending some four decades ago is so damaging today. Nor have they shown how those criticisms have manifest themselves into things Australia has not experienced such as prolonged sluggish economic growth, falling living standards, problems on the budget, chronic unemployment or whatever.

No substance, only high brow fact-free opinion and zealotry.

The scathing criticisms of Whitlam and his legacy need to be put in some context.

Since his sacking, some 39 years ago, the Coalition parties have been in power for about 20 years, so one would have thought that if the Whitlam legacy was so bad, so damaging, so horribly yukky, that Fraser’s seven years, Howard’s 11 and a half years and Abbott’s 13 months in office would have, in at least one of their budgets, scaled back, reversed and once and for all ended, the Whitlam economic legacy.

On that score, it is interesting to note that in 1975-76, government spending to GDP was 24.3 per cent. The Fraser government saw this rise to 25.8 per cent of GDP by 1982-83. (Not those bloody facts again!)

With Mr Hockey’s budget less than six months ago, government spending to GDP, even allowing for the cuts that were announced, was estimated to be 25.3 per cent of GDP in 2014-15 and at or above 24.7 per cent of GDP in every year of the forward estimates. So Abbott and Hockey’s small government budget had spending a bit lower that Fraser, but still above the ‘big spending’ Whitlam budgets.

That’s the first point to note.

Could it be the electorate like the government to have some role in health, education, aged and disability care?

My guess is ‘yes’. Look at the public’s reaction to the Abbott government’s proposed Medicare co-payment, university fee hikes and cuts to unemployment benefit eligibility.

It is also interesting to note that in the early 1970s, government spending in the US rose sharply, by around 3 per cent of GDP in about half a decade. Surely Gough did not influence Nixon and Ford to spend, spend, spend? Maybe the social changes of the 1960s and 1970s in the western world saw the electorate demand, and get, a greater role from government.

And a few final fiscal facts:

Whitlam government left zero net government debt to Fraser – in June 1976, net debt was minus 0.4 per cent of GDP (that is, the government had financial assets). When The Fraser government lost in 1983, it had boosted net government debt to 7.5 per cent of GDP.

When Whitlam left office, the tax to GDP ratio was around 20 per cent. The Howard government got this up to an all time record tax take exceeding 24 per cent of GDP (in today’s dollars, 4 per cent of GDP is a stonking $65 billion per year).

Even Mr Hockey’s ‘low tax’ budget has the tax take at 23.2 per cent of GDP by 2017-18, some 3 per cent of GDP above anything Whitlam achieved.

Small government, big government?

It is funny how facts can smash perceptions.

Footnote: All the data on spending and tax are from Mr Hockey’s budget papers.

Many Labor supporters therefore breathed a sigh of relief

Anthony Albanese speaks to the media at Parliament House on Friday.

The questionable loyalty of Anthony Albanese

Anthony Albanese broke ranks on Labor’s support for the Abbott government’s enhanced national security measures – but whose interests did he really serve by doing so?

Many Labor supporters therefore breathed a sigh of relief on Sunday when the opposition spokesman on infrastructure and transport Anthony Albanese broke ranks on the party’s support for the Abbott government’s enhanced national security measures.

Albanese became the first senior Labor MP to voice concern about the lack of parliamentary debate on the nevertheless bipartisan decision to participate in the joint military action in Iraq. More importantly, he cautioned that the new counter-terrorism laws had not received enough scrutiny by the parliament and, by implication, from the Labor party.

Albanese’s intervention has been welcomed, at least in some parts of the Labor camp, and certainly by supporters on social media. This small act of rebellion no doubt reinforced Albo’s standing as the darling of Labor’s left (who incidentally still feel they were robbed when their man won the popular vote for the Labor leadership but ultimately lost out to the powerbrokers of the right who used their numbers in the ALP caucus to install their man Shorten instead).

Whatever strategy Albanese has in play, either in trying to keep the disenchanted left in the Labor tent, or making Labor more competitive by wresting the leadership from Shorten, it’s hard to fault his overall motivation. Whatever his personal ambition, Labor’s fiercely tribal warrior exists mainly to “fight Tories” and see his beloved party returned to government.

But if Albo does hold greater ambitions for his party than he does for himself, he’d do well to remember one thing: there’s only one thing voters will reject quicker than an uncompetitive Labor party, and that’s one riddled with the internecine wars that brought down the Rudd and Gillard governments.